The State of AI/ML Benchmarking: Addressing Gaps and Driving Progress

By Arthur Kang, Machine Learning Committee Chair

In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML), enhancing the accuracy and computational efficiency of large models remains a critical challenge. As of 2024, there are over 100 commercial large language models worldwide, with OpenAI's ChatGPT boasting more than 500 million users. The swift development of these models is driving significant advances in AI capabilities.

As large models grow in complexity, the demand for computational power and the associated energy consumption—leading to substantial carbon emissions—has become a pressing issue. Improving model accuracy while optimizing computational efficiency is crucial to managing the high demands and costs associated with training and inference. Currently, however, there is a lack of standardized benchmarks for evaluating the computational efficiency of large models, and this lack makes it challenging to quantify performance across different models and ensure effective improvements in model capabilities, as well as overall cost reduction.

Establishing standardized ML benchmarks can provide a common measurement scale for enhancing comparability and guiding model enhancements. By promoting efficient resource utilization and improving model quality, standardized benchmarks will play a significant role in driving the global AI industry towards a more sustainable future. And now, through SPEC, organizations and individuals have an opportunity to help shape the development of these vital new benchmarks.

The Current State of AI/ML Benchmarking

The ongoing evolution in AI technologies, particularly in the development of large models, is driving unprecedented innovation. However, these technologies also place immense demands on computational resources, which underscores the urgency of optimizing both accuracy and efficiency. A key challenge for AI/ML researchers and developers is achieving greater accuracy without exponentially increasing computational demands, thereby keeping energy consumption and associated costs manageable.

While much progress has been made in AI/ML benchmarking, there are still considerable gaps in terms of standardized testing for large model computational efficiency, often referred to as "model efficiency." A particularly critical gap is in the context of large-scale model training and inference, which consume vast amounts of computational power and energy. Addressing these gaps is essential for both promoting innovation and ensuring a more sustainable and resource-efficient AI ecosystem.

Moreover, without a unified benchmark, it's difficult to compare models on a level playing field. The lack of standardization limits our ability to evaluate different AI models consistently, which in turn hampers efforts to guide meaningful improvements in both performance and energy efficiency.

Robust, unified benchmarks can facilitate:

• Better Comparability: A standardized system allows developers to compare different models using consistent metrics. This ensures that improvements in performance and energy efficiency are recognized across the industry.
• Enhanced Innovation: Clear benchmarks serve as a guiding framework, encouraging the development of more efficient models that meet both accuracy and sustainability goals. By quantifying model efficiency, we can identify areas for improvement and target innovations that truly push the boundaries of AI performance.
• Green Development: Perhaps most important, well-defined benchmarking standards

Collaborating on ML Benchmarking Initiatives with SPEC

SPEC’s initiatives in developing ML benchmarks are aligned with these needs and focus on setting standards that can address the missing elements in current benchmarking practices. While it is premature to discuss the specifics of the SPEC ML benchmarks, it is clear that any comprehensive benchmarking initiative must address the growing complexity of models and the associated computational challenges.

A crucial part of the success of this effort will involve greater collaboration across industries and research sectors. This collaboration is essential for enhancing the initiative's credibility and increasing its impact. To drive this forward, SPEC invites organizations and individuals to join its Machine Learning committee. By contributing to shaping standards, you can play a pivotal role in shaping the future of AI development.

Moreover, the Machine Learning committee presents an opportunity to explore alternative directions that diverge from traditional benchmarking, which could generate even more industry interest by offering novel approaches or technologies that collaborators may find exciting and worthwhile.

Conclusion: A Unified Effort for a Sustainable Future

As we move forward, establishing robust benchmarks for AI/ML models is more important than ever. A unified approach will not only help streamline model comparisons, but also pave the way for innovations that prioritize sustainability, efficiency, and accuracy. Through collaboration and collective effort with SPEC, the AI/ML community can address these challenges and help ensure that the development of large models contributes to a greener, more sustainable future for the entire industry and the world.

[Back to SPEC blog]